Let’s Talk About Shock Collars: Honesty, History, and Responsibility

The Truth About E-Collars: Transparency and Responsible Use

Okay, let’s get real for a moment. If you’re in the dog training world, or even just a curious dog owner, you’ve probably heard about E-Collars—or as some people call them, “shock collars.” And this is where things get a little sticky because the minute someone says “shock collar,” the conversation can quickly turn into a mess of accusations, finger-pointing, and defensiveness.

Trust me—I’ve worn one myself. Ever tried playing ping pong while bracing for a surprise “zing”? I’ll tell you that story later.

So, let’s slow this down. Let’s talk about what they are, where they came from, and why avoiding the term “shock collar” might not be helping anyone—least of all, the dogs.

Owning the Truth—Yes, They Used to Be Called Shock Collars

Here’s the thing: words matter. Pretending like the phrase “shock collar” doesn’t exist doesn’t make it go away. It also doesn’t do us any favors. Because the truth is, when these tools were first introduced decades ago, they were called shock collars.

Let’s go back to the 1950s, when the first shock collars—or e-collars—were invented by two bird-dog hunters. These hunters used the collars to correct the behavior of their dogs while tracking mountain lions in the Southwestern United States. The original e-collars were designed with just three shock levels, all of which were very aversive, comparable to the jolt from an electric fence.

For the time, this technology was seen as groundbreaking. It gave hunters a way to communicate with their dogs over long distances, keeping them safe and on task in environments where verbal commands couldn’t reach. But there’s no sugar-coating it: these early devices were basic and rough around the edges. They lacked the precision and versatility we have today, and their use often caused discomfort that went well beyond what we’d consider acceptable by modern standards.

Acknowledging this history isn’t about shaming the past—it’s about understanding how far we’ve come. Those early collars were a product of their time, just like any invention. And the evolution from those early tools to the highly adjustable, refined devices we use today is a testament to the advancements in dog training philosophy, technology, and ethics.

Why Being Honest About the Name Matters

I get it—calling them “shock collars” feels like you’re waving a red flag to critics. But let’s be honest here: avoiding the term can backfire. It makes us sound like we’re trying to hide something, and nothing builds mistrust faster than a lack of transparency.

The minute someone thinks, “Why are they dancing around the name? What are they hiding?” the conversation shifts. Instead of educating, we end up defending. Instead of building trust, we create more skepticism. And let me tell you—no one learns when their walls are up.

The truth? E-Collars deliver electrical stimulation. That’s not something to deny or tiptoe around. But here’s the important part:

•The stimulation is adjustable and can be incredibly subtle.

•The goal isn’t to punish—it’s to communicate.

•Used properly, they can give dogs freedom, confidence, and safety that other tools sometimes can’t.

When we’re honest about what these tools are—and what they aren’t—we invite curiosity instead of conflict. We create a space for understanding instead of judgment.

The Technology Has Evolved, and So Have We

It’s fascinating when you think about it: those early collars were seen as revolutionary at the time, but they lacked the precision and versatility we have today. Now, modern E-Collars are light-years ahead:

•Adjustable stimulation: With dozens of levels, trainers can find the lowest, most subtle setting a dog can feel—something as gentle as a tap on the shoulder.

•Multiple modes: Tone, vibration, and momentary stimulation allow for refined communication that works for the individual dog.

•Training philosophy: Today’s ethical trainers combine E-Collars with positive reinforcement, creating clarity and trust—not fear.

This isn’t the harsh tool of the 1960s. The tool has evolved. We’ve evolved. And that’s worth talking about.

E-Collar Ping Pong: A Lesson in Perception

Alright, here’s a story that might make you laugh and think. Back in our 20s, we had this thing—call it creative, call it ridiculous, but it made for a pretty unforgettable night.

We had a one-collar, two-remote system, which meant both players wore E-Collars on their wrists while playing ping pong. The twist? A third person got the remotes and could deliver a “shock” to either player at any moment.

Now, I need to explain something about how these collars feel—because people hear “shock” and assume it’s like grabbing a live wire. It’s not. It’s more like a TENS unit, the kind you’d use at a physiotherapy clinic to stimulate your muscles. The moment that button was pressed, your muscles would contract involuntarily, and if you weren’t braced for it, you’d end up launching your paddle across the room like a slingshot.

But here’s where the real competition came in: none of us wanted to lose the game. So what did we do? We gripped those paddles for dear life—white-knuckling it, sweating, and swearing under our breath—determined not to let a little muscle contraction get the best of us. At the higher levels (and yes, we cranked it up to 100), it hurt. I won’t lie. It was a sharp, startling zing that shot through your arm and made you double down. But here’s the kicker: it still wasn’t enough for any of us to quit.

Why? Because losing that ping pong game was way worse than the collar going off.

Looking back, it’s a hilarious memory that sticks with me because it highlights something important about how we experience discomfort: context and perception matter. The “shock” wasn’t unbearable—it was surprising. It was manageable. And most of all, it had meaning: “Don’t lose this game. Hold onto that paddle.”

It’s Not the Tool—It’s How We Use It

Let’s clear something up: no tool, on its own, is good or bad. A leash can be used to gently guide or to yank. A crate can be a safe haven or a source of fear. The same is true for E-Collars. It all comes down to who’s using the tool and how.

•In responsible hands: An E-Collar is like a seatbelt—it provides safety, clarity, and confidence. It helps dogs learn boundaries and skills while still enjoying off-leash freedom.

•In irresponsible hands: Any tool, E-Collar included, can be harmful. That’s why education and accountability are so important.

This isn’t about pretending E-Collars don’t have a controversial past. It’s about owning that past, acknowledging the advancements, and showing people how far we’ve come.

Freedom, Not Fear

I want to leave you with this: E-Collars, when used correctly, are not cruel. They’re not “shortcuts” or “lazy training,” either. For many dogs, they’re tools that allow them to explore, run, play, and enjoy a freedom they wouldn’t otherwise have. For many owners, they’re tools that bring peace of mind—knowing their dog is safe, secure, and responsive, even in tough environments.

But we don’t build trust by hiding behind language. We build trust by being honest, transparent, and compassionate. And if a stubborn 20-something me could grip a paddle through level-100 zaps and laugh about it later, imagine how manageable a properly-used E-Collar feels for a dog at level 3. It’s not about pain. It’s about communication.

Yes, they were once called shock collars. Yes, they’ve come a long way. And yes, the way we use them now is all about helping dogs thrive—not just survive.

So let’s have the conversation. Let’s answer the hard questions. And let’s keep the focus on what really matters: doing right by the dogs we love.

Ready to Take Your Training Further?

Understanding tools like E-Collars is just the beginning. Whether you’re looking to strengthen your dog’s recall, improve their focus, or build reliable behaviors, we’re here to help you every step of the way.

Explore our Online Courses or check out our Building Food Motivation PDF on Etsy for actionable, step-by-step guidance that makes training clear, effective, and fun.

Curious about the people behind Training Dogs Online? Get to know the trainers and why we’re passionate about helping dogs and their owners succeed.

– Cher Wood

Street Wise Canine